NYC Councilman Justin Brannan Ousted From Italian Caucus Over Columbus Day Controversy

Justin Brannan, a Brooklyn Democrat and candidate for city comptroller, has been removed from the New York City Council’s Italian Caucus after clashing with the group over his stance on Columbus Day. Brannan’s suggestion that the holiday could be renamed Italian-American Heritage Day led to his removal from the predominantly conservative caucus.

The caucus, chaired by Councilman David Carr (R-Staten Island), revised its bylaws after Brannan’s 2023 comments to ensure that all members fully support Columbus Day. Carr explained that there was no room for negotiation on retaining the holiday as it is.

Brannan, who is of Italian descent, defended his position, stating that he remains proud of his heritage but rejects what he called a “MAGA litmus test.” He argued that Columbus Day is about celebrating Italian-American contributions, not just Columbus himself.

The disagreement came to a head when Brannan was excluded from the City Council’s Italian Heritage Celebration. Fellow caucus member Councilman Robert Holden (D-Queens) supported the decision, accusing Brannan of embracing modern “woke” trends rather than defending Italian traditions.

The Italian Caucus remains committed to preserving Columbus Day in its current form and continues to resist efforts to rename the holiday. Brannan’s removal highlights the ongoing debate over the holiday’s place in American culture.